
Every year, with the announcement of the Academy Awards nominations, everybody gets to see if their favorite movies, actors and actresses got recognition for whatever it is they did during the past year, even if it was just blatantly so their names would be appear on such a list. (I’m looking at you everybody associated with The King’s Speech). But many people forget that there are far more categories featuring the names of people you’ve never heard of than those that do, including those of the Live Action and Animated Short Film.
For the past few weeks, all over the country, select theaters have been playing the Academy Award nominated shorts for those who didn’t have the opportunity to see them in whatever festivals they happened to screen at over the last year. So, in order to have the edge on my Oscar ballot this year, I went to one of these screenings just to see what kind of filmmakers they’re giving these awards to, and who had the most potential to walk away a winner this coming Sunday.
So, here are all of the Live Action and Animated Short Films that were nominated this year, along with a few words about each of them, and who I think should and will win.
Best Animated Short Films:
The Cow Who Wanted To Be A Hamburger (USA)

As a fan of Bill Plympton, I wasn’t surprised to love his new animated short about a young calf who is influenced by persuasive billboard to dream of becoming a hamburger. Despite the short’s length, Plympton’s signature style and humor is apparent, even if the story is pretty simple. Seeing the lengths the titular calf goes to in order to make his dreams come true, while knowing what achieving it entails as the audience, and seeing his reaction, creates some really funny moments. It’s surprising that this was only screened as “Highly Commended” seeing as it was better than most of the other shorts screened that were actually nominated.
9 out of 10.
Urs (Germany)

Another “Highly Commended” selection, Urs tells the story of a son trying to take his mother from their rural, old cabin to a more populated town, despite her unwillingness to leave. There’s nothing particularly wrong with Urs, but there’s not much that’s compelling about it either, with some pretty plain visuals, and nothing on the animation front that would’ve been considered impressive for at least the last fifteen years. Overall, nothing that memorable, but not for a lack of competent storytelling.
6 out of 10.
Madagascar: A Journey Diary (France)

For the first of the actual nominees, Madagascar: A Journey Diary, here, as opposed to the plainness of Urs story and visuals, we have a pretty cool mix of traditionally hand drawn, computer generated, and seemingly rotoscoped animation, all based around director Bastian DuBois’s trip to the titular country. However, while the animation was all very impressive and presented as basically a moving scrapbook of the trip, that’s all it ended up being. Moving from scenic location to scenic location, loosely tied together by the singular point of view of its director, Madagascar never really tells a story or develops anything but its concept of being a colorful record of a trip. And while some of the brief history and practice of native traditions, as well as the non-stop action of the trip, keep things interesting enough to fill a few minutes, the lack of any connection to the people participating keep the short from being very memorable.
7 out of 10.
Let’s Pollute (USA)

In what was probably the most excruciating short of the program and the nominees, Let’s Pollute is an extremely obvious and heavy-handed satire aimed at telling you all of the wonderful reasons why its great to pollute. Explaining America’s legacy of destroying the Earth, as well as discussing pollution’s importance to modern industry and life, Let’s Pollute talks so far down to its audience, it ends up having its head stuck up its own ass by the end of the seemingly unending five-minute run time. It’s one thing to try and use satire to get your point across, but when the majority of people you’re explaining your wild theories about how pollution doesn’t work have been on your side for the last thirty years, it only makes your short seem dated and pointless.
4 out of 10.
The Gruffalo (UK/Germany)

Adapted from a children’s book of the same name, The Gruffalo features an all-star British cast in the telling of what’s essentially a fable about brains vs. brawn. As a story being told by a mother squirrel (voiced by Helena Bonham Carter) to her children, The Gruffalo follows a mouse searching for a distant tree full of golden acorns, and the difficulties he faces along the way. Being based on a children’s book, there aren’t many surprises, and things do get repetitive and little too cute at times, but the style of the animation and conviction of its voice actors (who probably took the work for the fun of it, based on their performances) make The Gruffalo the most accessible and fun of the nominees, at least, if you’re under the age of five.
8 out of 10.
The Lost Thing (UK/Australia)

Another nominee based on a children’s book, this one created by co-director Shaun Tan, The Lost Thing tells the story of a guy who finds, well, a “thing” one day, and his attempts to help it be found. While the computer animation is pretty standard, the character design of the titular “thing”, as well as the many other “things” featured help distinguish the short, and the world created in it, as something unique. Combined with a memorable message about keeping the perspective of an idealist, and the loss of the ability to see this kind of uniqueness with age, makes The Lost Thing one of the better shorts of the program.
8 out of 10.
Day & Night (USA)

As a Pixar junkie, I’m sure there’s no objective way for me to judge their work, especially their shorts, which are always impressive works, jamming tons of character, humor and meaning into the few minutes each of them lasts. And Day & Night is no different. Looking at the relationship between the personifications of Night and Day as characters, each with their own benefits and impressive qualities, the short takes a weird, but not bad, turn near the end, as it becomes a moral take on the importance of embracing the differences of others. The combination of the two-dimensional characters and their three-dimensional insides, as well as some creative uses of sound and location to add to the action and humor, is pretty brilliant, as is the concept itself. While I’m always rooting for Pixar to win, despite the competition, I truly do believe that theirs is the best short of this list of nominees, and they deserve to and will win on Sunday night.
9 out of 10.
Well, I’ll see you tomorrow with my reviews of the Best Live Action Short Films, which, while not as entertaining as this batch, were interesting to watch nonetheless.